HomeMy WebLinkAboutCC Min 1988-02-01
1-18-88 / 2-1-88
Approved:
~t.'~A ~..J
Mayor
Attest:
Seal Beach, California
February 1, 1988
The City Council of the City of Seal Beach met in regular
session at 7:00 p.m. with Mayor Wilson calling the meeting
to order with the Salute to the Flag.
I
ROLL CALL
Present:
Mayor Wilson
Councilmembers Clift, Hunt, Risner
Absent:
Councilman Grgas
Also present: Mr. Nelson, City Manager
Mr. Rudell, Assistant City Attorney
Mr. Joseph, Assistant City Manager
Chief Stearns, Police Department
Mr. Knight, Director of Development Services
Mrs. Yeo, City Clerk
Mayor Wilson announced the untimely death of Mr. Dudley
Hemphill, Director of Public Works/City Engineer, and those
present observed a moment of silence in his memory. The
City Manager advised that City Hall would be closed from
10:00 a.m. until 1:00 p.m. the following day to allow I
employees and friends to attend a memorial service for Mr. -
Hemphill.
AGENDA AMENDED
Risner moved, second by Hunt, to amend the agenda to
consider Items "G" and "V" as first items of business.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
WAIVER OF FULL READING
Clift moved, second by Wilson, to waive the reading in full
of all ordinances and resolutions and that consent to the
waiver of reading shall be deemed to be given by all
Councilmembers after reading of the title unless specific
request is made at that time for the reading of such
ordinance or resolution.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
ITEM "G" - RESOLUTION NUMBER 3755 - STORM ASSISTANCE - I
HUNTINGTON BEACH JEEP-EAGLE
Resolution Number 3755 was presented to Council entitled "A
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SEAL BEACH,
CALIFORNIA, EXPRESSING APPRECIATION TO HUNTINGTON BEACH
JEEP-EAGLE DEALER FOR THEIR ASSISTANCE DURING THE JANUARY
1988 STORMS." By unanimous consent, full reading of
Resolution Number 3755 was waived. Clift moved, second by
Hunt, to adopt Resolution Number 3755 as presented.
2-1-88
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
Mayor Wilson presented the Resolution to representatives of
the Huntington Beach Jeep-Eagle Dealership present in the
audience.
I
ITEM "V" - DONATION REQUEST - LEISURE WORLD FRIENDS OF THE
LIBRARY
Councilman Hunt reported the efforts to date of the Friends
of the Library in raising $33,000 of the $50,000 needed for
the construction of a building adjacent to the Leisure World
Library, that building to be used primarily by the Friends
to provide community services to residents of Leisure World.
Mr. Hunt explained that the Friends must make a commitment
to the County for the $50,000 in order to receive County
funding of approximately $78,000, and asked that the Council
consider making a $3,000 commitment to this cause, possibly
in the 1988/89 budget. Ms. Celeste Kraus, President of the
Friends, stated that a primary use of the new facility will
be a permanent book store which provides a source of income
that can in turn be used for the benefit of the library to
provide books on tape, videos, assistance to shut-ins, etc.
The City Manager advised that it may be possible to fund
this request from the 1987/88 unallocated reserves.
Clift moved, second by Hunt, to commit $3,000 towards the
construction of the subject building, either at the end of
this fiscal year or that it be included in the 1988/89
budget. The Assistant City Attorney clarified that as a
non-profit organization that is a benefit to the City, there
would be no prohibition of making the commitment as stated.
I
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
I
PRESENTATION - HAZARDOUS MATERIALS TEAM
Ms. Karen Peters, Manager of the Hazardous Materials Program
for the Orange County Fire Department, presented an overview
of the plan being formulated to comply with AB 2948, the
Tanner bill, and SB 650, with regard to disposal, storage
and transportation of hazardous waste materials. Ms. Peters
stated that eight public hearings have been scheduled
county-wide, and that as much public input as possible is
being sought since this plan will determine what type of
hazardous waste facilities will be available for treatment
in the future, and noted the deadlines for public comments,
submittal of the draft plan to the State, etc. Ms. Peters
stated it is critical that the City review the plan as
drafted, the goals and objectives set forth therein, with
particular attention to Appendix D to the plan, the siting
criteria proposed for treatment facilities. She also
advised that the Environmental Impact Report will be
forthcoming to the City for review, and that by the end of
the year it will be necessary for the City to take some
action to amend its General Plan, as mandated by SB 477, to
reflect the plan approved by the State Department of Health
Services. She noted that there is also investigation as to
what can be done on a regional basis, as well as private
sector development of hazardous waste facilities. At the
request of Council, Ms. Peters explained that the Southern
California Hazardous Waste Management Authority was formed
in 1985 to look at the regional approach to solving
hazardous waste issues, and further described the
composition of the Authority's membership. She explained
that the net result of city obligations is that if
2-1-88
appropriate treatment facilities are not provided the cost
of hazardous waste disposal will be borne by all cities,
also that if a plan is not provided, the State Department of
Health Services could, by State statute, overrule local land
use decisions. She pointed out that no city is exempt from
a site location, such as that of a transfer station, until
each city is looked at and specific criteria is met to
protect public health, adding that it is also felt more
pressure will be placed on the military to work with local
government to insure proper response plans and siting
criteria for anything that may be developed on military I
land. Ms. Peters explained that a residual depository is a
new name for dump, a landfill that would receive hazardous
waste after being through a treatment process and stored in
an appropriate manner, noting also the need for a residual
depository somewhere in the Southern California area. Mayor
Wilson expressed appreciation for Ms. Peters' presentation.
PUBLIC HEARING - BUILDING CODES
Mayor Wilson declared the public hearing open to consider
adoption of the 1985 Uniform Building and Fire Code and
amendments thereto. The City Clerk certified that notice of
the public hearing had been published as required by law and
reported no communications had been received either for or
against this item. The Director of Development Services
presented the staff report, noting specifically the
amendment of building sprinkler requirements as proposed by
the County Fire Service. He explained that the amendment
proposed would require sprinklers if a new building is 6,000
square feet or larger, or greater than two stories, and
throughout all new R-l, multiple family occupancies, however
would only affect new construction and would not include
additions, rehabs, or reconstruction of existing units that
have been destroyed. He added that the staff had notified
local contractors, the Bixby Company and the Building I
Industry of Orange County of the proposed amendments. He
reported that each contract city for fire service has
adopted the amendments to date, the County, however
rejecting the amendment, and reported it is the intent of
County Fire to resubmit the fire sprinkler provisions to the
County for consideration later in the year. Mr. Knight
stated that the staff does support the amendments as an
effective method to increase life safety and reduce property
loss in the case of a fire.
Mayor Wilson invited members of the audience wishing to
speak to this item to come to the microphone and state their
name and address for the record. Mr. Jim Stone, Orange
County Fire Marshall, requested Council support of adoption
of the 1985 Fire Code and proposed amendments thereto as
described by the staff report. Mr. Stone explained that the
sprinkling requirements would apply to three or more units,
multi-family dwellings being of greatest concern, and that
it has been found that sprinkler systems are about ninety-
seven percent effective in protecting lives over other forms
of fire safety systems, as well as being cost effective. He
added that the 6,000 square foot amendment would pertain to
commercial buildings that are not presently required to be
sprinklered, that under present Code 12,000 square foot
buildings require sprinkling dependent upon the use of those I
buildings, and that the amendment to 6,000 square feet, in
the long term, will tend to hold down the cost of fire
protection and decrease the need for additional resources in
the future. Mr. Bruce Stark, 204 Ocean Avenue, noted his
experience with the sprinkler fitting industry, and spoke in
support of sprinkler systems and their effectiveness,
however stated such systems are expensive and that that
should be a matter of consideration. He also stated such
2-1-88
I
systems are not an extension of the cold water system, as
stated at a previous meeting, but requires a separate, high
pressure line from the water main into the dwelling, with
installation of special high pressure plumbing. Mr. Stark
took some exception to provision of the proposed Ordinance
with regard to inspections and the City's recourse through
all remedies of law. Mr. Stone responded that a residential
sprinkler system is an extension of the cold water system,
not requiring the expensive underground piping, a typical
residential dwelling of eight hundred to one thousand square
feet requiring about six sprinkler heads, the cost ranging
from approximately fifty to ninety cents per square foot or
$700, in most cases the more sprinklers the lesser the cost,
also that some insurance companies are offering lower rates
for sprinklered dwellings. There being no further comments
from the audience, Mayor Wilson declared the public hearing
closed.
I
RESOLUTION NUMBER 3753 - MODIFICATIONS TO CODES - LOCAL
CONDITIONS
Resolution Number 3753 was presented to Council entitled "A
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SEAL BEACH,
SETTING FORTH THE LOCAL CONDITIONS UPON WHICH A
DETERMINATION HAS BEEN MADE BY THE CITY COUNCIL THAT
MODIFICATIONS TO CERTAIN OF THE FOLLOWING CODE ARE
REASONABLY REQUIRED BY LOCAL CONDITIONS WITHIN THE CITY OF
SEAL BEACH: THE 1985 EDITION OF THE UNIFORM BUILDING CODE,
THE 1985 EDITION OF THE UNIFORM MECHANICAL CODE, THE 1985
EDITION OF THE UNIFORM PLUMBING CODE, THE 1985 EDITION OF
THE UNIFORM SWIMMING POOL CODE; THE 1985 EDITION OF THE
UNIFORM HOUSING CODE, THE 1985 EDITION OF THE UNIFORM FIRE
CODE, THE 1985 EDITION OF THE UNIFORM SOLAR ENERGY CODE, AND
THE 1987 EDITION OF THE NATIONAL ELECTRICAL CODE." By
unanimous consent, full reading of Resolution Number 3753
was waived. Risner moved, second by Clift, to adopt
Resolution Number 3753 as presented.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
I
ORDINANCE NUMBER 1267 - ADOPTING BUILDING AND SAFETY CODES
Ordinance Number 1267 was presented to Council for second
reading entitled "AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE
CITY OF SEAL BEACH, CALIFORNIA, AMENDING CHAPTER 5 OF THE
CODE OF THE CITY OF SEAL BEACH RELATING TO BUILDING AND
SAFETY AND ADOPTING BY REFERENCE THE FOLLOWING CODES WITH
AMENDMENTS: THE UNIFORM BUILDING CODE, 1985 EDITION,
INCLUDING THE APPENDIX, THE UNIFORM MECHANICAL CODE, 1985
EDITION, THE UNIFORM PLUMBING CODE, 1985 EDITION, THE
UNIFORM SWIMMING POOL CODE, 1985 EDITION; THE UNIFORM
HOUSING CODE, 1985 EDITION, THE UNIFORM CODE FOR THE
ABATEMENT OF DANGEROUS BUILDINGS, 1985 EDITION, THE UNIFORM
SIGN CODE, 1985 EDITION, THE NATIONAL ELECTRICAL CODE 1987
EDITION, THE UNIFORM BUILDING CODE STANDARDS, 1985 EDITION,
THE UNIFORM FIRE CODE, 1985 EDITION, INCLUDING THE APPENDIX,
THE UNIFORM FIRE CODE STANDARDS, 1985 EDITION, THE UNIFORM
SOLAR ENERGY CODE, 1985 EDITION." By unanimous consent,
full reading of Ordinance Number 1267 was waived.
Councilmember Risner suggested that Section II(b)(6),
amending the Uniform Building Code, and Section 8(B)(9),
amending the Uniform Fire Code, be amended to read
"Throughout all new R-l occupancies, including enclosed
garages, for projects exceeding fifteen units or greater"
and so moved. Councilman Hunt seconded the motion for
discussion. The Development Services Director explained
that the reference to fifteen units would reflect a local
amendment, not a provision adopted by the State.
2-1-88
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
Councilman Hunt moved that the 12,000 square foot figure be
reflected in Section II(b)(5), amending the Uniform Building
Code, and Section 8(B)(5), amending the Uniform Fire Code,
rather than 6,000 square feet. The Development Services
Director explained that the current local Building Code
reflects 12,000 square feet. Mr. Stone reported that the
State Code does not address square footage specifically, nor I
does the type of construction make a difference, the use of
a structure being the important factor. Councilman Hunt
withdrew his motion. Mr. Knight explained further that
current Code reflects different standards for different
occupancies. Discussion continued.
Clift moved, second by Risner, to adopt Ordinance Number
1267 as amended.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
By unanimous consent of the Council, Mayor Wilson declared a
recess at 8:35 p.m. The Council reconvened at 8:48 p.m.
with Mayor Wilson calling the meeting to order.
ORDINANCE NUMBER 1268 - CABLEVISION FRANCHISE AGREEMENT -
AMENDMENT NUMBER FIVE
Ordinance Number 1268 was presented to Council for second
reading entitled "AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SEAL BEACH
APPROVING AMENDMENT NUMBER FIVE TO THE FRANCHISE AGREEMENT
BETWEEN THE CITY OF SEAL BEACH AND COMCAST CABLEVISION." By
unanimous consent, full reading of Ordinance Number 1268 was
waived. Risner moved, second by Clift, to adopt Ordinance
Number 1268 as presented.
I
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
ORDINANCE NUMBER 1269 - UTILITY USERS TAX - AMENDMENT
Ordinance Number 1269 was presented to Council for first
reading entitled "AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SEAL BEACH
AMENDING CHAPTER 22, ARTICLE VIII OF THE CODE OF THE CITY OF
SEAL BEACH, CALIFORNIA, RELATING TO THE UTILITY USERS TAX."
By unanimous consent, full reading of Ordinance Number 1269
was waived. The Assistant City Manager presented the staff
report, explaining that the proposed Ordinance provides for
a grace period for payment of utility user's tax when the
due date occurs on a weekend or legal holiday, also
addresses cogeneration and energy produced by such
technology. The City Attorney noted that although the grace
period was requested by Southern California Edison, the
Ordinance allows the same grace period for the other
utilities subject to the Utility Users Tax. Clift moved,
second by Hunt, to approve the introduction of Ordinance
Number 1269 and that it be passed to second reading.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
I
RESOLUTION NUMBER 3754 - APPRECIATION - JANUARY 1988 STORM
ASSISTANCE
Resolution Number 3754 was presented to Council and read in
full by Mayor Wilson entitled "A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY
2-1-88
COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SEAL BEACH, CALIFORNIA, EXPRESSING
GRATITUDE TO ALL CITY EMPLOYEES, ORANGE COUNTY FIRE
DEPARTMENT AND THE ORANGE COUNTY ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
AGENCY FOR THEIR ASSISTANCE DURING THE JANUARY 1988 STORMS."
Clift moved, second by Risner, to adopt Resolution Number
3754 as presented.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
I
CONSENT CALENDAR - ITEMS "H" THROUGH "P"
Councilmember Risner requested that Item "N" be removed from
the Consent Calendar. Risner moved, second by Clift, to
approve the recommended action for items on the Consent
Calendar, except Item "N", as presented.
H. Approved the minutes of the regular meeting
of December 7, 1987.
I. Approved the minutes of the regular meeting
of December 21, 1987.
J. Approved regular demands numbered 68618
through 68815 in the amount of $601,669.73
and payroll demands numbered 28990 through
29145 in the amount of $167,516.29 as
approved by the Finance Committee, and
authorized warrants to be drawn on the
Treasury for same.
I
K. Denied the claim filed on behalf of
Elizabeth J. Madsen and referred same to
the City's insurance adjuster.
L. Denied the claim of Katherine Neil and
referred same to the City's insurance
adjuster.
M. Authorized a senior citizen discount for
tram rides for those qualified senior
citizens patronizing Ruby's Jewel Cafe.
O. Awarded the purchase order for an emergency
generator for the Water Department to
Equipment Service Company, the sole bidder,
in the amount of $35,433.68.
P. Authorized the use of City Council Chambers
on April 10, 1988 for an Eagle Scout Court
of Honor for John McCabe, Seal Beach resident.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
I
ITEMS REMOVED FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR
ITEM "Nil - EARTHOUAKE/PIER INSURANCE
The Assistant City Manager reported that the City is in
receipt of quotes to provide earthquake insurance for City
Hall, the Old City Hall, the Police Facility and the
Municipal Pier, two of the quotes providing wave wash
coverage with a $250,000 deductible. The Council commended
the staff for their efforts towards obtaining such coverage.
Risner moved, second by Clift, to allocate $46,004 from the
General Fund balance to account 001-019-000-453 for the
purchase of earthquake and pier insurance.
2-1-88
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
MID-YEAR BUDGET REVIEW
The Assistant City Manager reviewed in detail the mid-year
budget status report, providing an update of administrative
accomplishments, and a review of the City's fiscal condition
through December 31, 1987. Mr. Joseph asked that the
Council consider a budget amendment to allocate $4800 for
the retention of ATMI telephone consultants for the purpose
of preparing plans and specifications, request for proposal
and RFP analysis for a new telephone system at the Police
Department, which will result in a long term cost saving to
the City. He also requested consideration of retaining a
consultant to prepare the necessary information for Council
to consider implementing a street lighting assessment
district. Mr. Joseph advised that the staff will be looking
further into revision of the business license fee,
implementation of the street sweeping and tree trimming fee
previously approved by the Council, and proposed changes in
various fees for services. In response to Council, the City
Manager advised that it is felt that the work of the
assessment district consultant will be lessened due to the
information that is available from a previous street
lighting assessment district, however pointed out the need
for quality information to develop the benefit spread, and
noted that the cost relating thereto will be covered by the
assessment.
Risner moved, second by Hunt, to receive the mid-year budget
report, authorize $4800 to retain ATMI telephone consultants
to prepare plans and specifications, RFP analysis for a new
telephone system for the Police Department, and authorize
the staff to retain a consultant for the purpose of
preparing the street lighting assessment district.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
COMPREHENSIVE FINANCIAL PLAN
The City Manager reported that the City is in receipt of a
proposal from Cranston Securities Company to prepare a
comprehensive financial plan for the City, the cost of such
plan estimated between $15,000 and $20,000, and reviewed the
various components to prepare a financial plan. He also
asked that the Council appoint two of its members to meet
with the staff and Cranston Securities to explore in greater
depth the potential benefits of such plan. Councilmember
Risner indicated her preference that City staff prepare much
of the information that would be required for a
comprehensive financial plan. The City Manager responded
that the staff does not possess all of the expertise that
would be required, and if this were an in-house project,
other workload would be delayed. A representative of
Cranston Securities concurred that much of the necessary
work could be accomplished by City staff, stating that
Cranston would act as a facilitator to bring all of the
City's financial resources together, the goal being to build
a consensus of staff and Council for long term financial
planning, adding that Cranston Securities would be willing
to review the scope of work contained in their proposal at
no cost to the City.
Clift moved, second by Risner, to approve the recommendation
of the City Manager to appoint Councilmembers Hunt and
Risner as a Council Committee to meet with the staff and
I
I
I
2-1-88
Cranston Securities, and to make a recommendation to the
City Council if there is a desire to retain the services of
Cranston Securities to develop a comprehensive financial
plan.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
I
ZOETER UPDATE
The City Manager reported that through the escrow process it
was found that the Zoeter property is listed in the name of
Seal Beach Bay City School District of Orange County, which
should soon be resolved, and that the parcel map is awaiting
the approval of the County Engineering staff, afterwhich it
is anticipated that escrow will close.
MEASURE "A"
The City Manager presented an expanded administrative
analysis of Initiative Measure "A", stating that after
receipt of the analysis of the City Attorney, the staff
devoted considerable time reviewing the numerous provisions
of the Initiative document and the assumptions and
conclusions with regard to the impact on the City's
administration, concluding that the Measure is bad
legislation, ambiguous, and conflicting with existing law,
if adopted it would be costly to implement, and in his
opinion would not achieve what the proponents claim with few
exceptions, and asked that the Council make this report
available to anyone requesting same. At the request of the
Council, Mr. Nelson reviewed indepth the impact of the
Initiative, if adopted, on the efforts of the City to
acquire the Zoeter School property. The Council received
the City Manager's administrative analysis of Measure "A".
I
DONATION REQUEST - IMAGINATION CELEBRATION
The City Manager reported receipt of a communication from
the California Alliance for Arts Education, Orange County
Performing Arts Center, requesting an unspecified donation
towards the Imagination Celebration, a countywide art
festival. Clift moved, second by Risner, to receive and
file the request.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Clift, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None
Grgas
Motion carried
APPOINTMENT - PROJECT AREA COMMITTEE
In the absence of Councilman Grgas, the Council held over
the District One appointment to the Project Area Committee.
CITY COUNCIL ITEMS
Councilmember Risner requested that Resolutions be prepared
for consideration of the Council recognizing the one
hundredth anniversary of the City of Long Beach, and the
sixtieth anniversary of the incorporation of the City of San
Clemente.
I
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
There were no Oral Communications.
CLOSED SESSION
No Closed Session was held.
ADJOURNMENT
Risner moved, second by Clift, to adjourn the meeting at
9:48 p.m.
2-1-88 / 2-16-88
/'
clerk of the
Approved: - ~ i:..:JAd.p~
Att..., 8~::Y~( fJ
I
Seal Beach, California
February 16, 1988
The City Council of the City of Seal Beach met in regular
session at 7:00 p.m. with Mayor Wilson calling the meeting
to order. Councilman Grgas led the Salute to the Flag.
ROLL CALL
Present:
Mayor Wilson
Councilmembers Clift, Hunt, Grgas, Risner
Absent:
None
Also present: Mr. Joseph, Assistant City Manager
Mr. Rudell, Assistant City Attorney
Mrs. Yeo, City Clerk
WAIVER OF FULL READING I
Risner moved, second by Clift, to waive the reading in full
of all ordinances and resolutions and that consent to the
waiver of reading shall be deemed to be given by all
Councilmembers after reading of the title unless specific
request is made at that time for the reading of such
ordinance or resolution.
AYES:
NOES:
Clift, Grgas, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None Motion carried
REQUEST - LOS ALAMITOS HIGH SCHOOL SHOW CHOIR
Seal Beach residents Ms. Vanessa Gonzales and Ms. Julie
Siler advised the Council of the opportunity for the Los
Alamitos High School Show Choir to attend the Young
Americans National Invitational Choir Festival in April
1988, representing the State of California and the cities of
Seal Beach and Los Alamitos. They explained that it is
necessary for the Choir to raise $15,000 to fund attendance
at this competition, and advised that one means of raising
funds to meet that goal will be through a benefit concert to
be held March 5th at the Los Alamitos High School theatre
and that tickets are available for purchase at a cost of
$20. After brief discussion, Risner moved, second by Clift,
to authorize a contribution of $200 to the School Choir I
funding raising effort.
AYES:
NOES:
Clift, Grgas, Hunt, Risner, Wilson
None Motion carried
REOUEST - ANNUAL EASTER PARADE
Mr. Jim Klisanin, Easter Parade Chairman, requested City
support of the 8th annual Easter Parade through the services
rendered by the Public Works, Police and Recreation